Check if any of the $656M in unclaimed royalties at The MLC is yours

Hi HN, I built this. Quick background on why it exists:When music is streamed on digital streaming platforms (think Spotify, Apple Music, Pandora), there are two separate royalty streams: one for the recording, paid through your distributor (DistroKid, TuneCore, CDBaby), and one for the underlying work (generally known as publishing). The work side's mechanical royalties are collected by The MLC, a nonprofit that was created by the 2018 Music Modernization Act (MMA). If you haven't registered your songs with The MLC, there are issues with your metadata, or about half a dozen other reasons, that money will never reach you, it just collects in a big pile we call the "black box".That pile is big. The MLC's own dashboard currently shows over $656M is held (themlc.com/blanket-royalties), and the biggest problem is the MMA dictates that The MLC cannot hold that money indefinitely. At some point, by law, The MLC must distribute this big pile of cash, and since they don't know who it's supposed to go to, they pay it out through a process called "market share" (themlc.com/marketshare). Market share means they pay it out, pro-rata, to the artists, songwriters and publishers that are in the system, which in practice means the largest publishers collect most of the leftovers.This is slated to begin in January 2027 and will pay portions of the pool out monthly (themlc.com/unclaimed-accrued-royalties), as of this morning, the next 12 months of market share sums up to $76.61M, starting with $6.41M in January.Full disclosure: I run Doubly, which is an independent publishing administrator, so I have a commercial interest in this space. That being said, we're a team of two people and we don't have the bandwidth to directly assist the hundreds of thousands of artists and songwriters who are going to start losing this money in January 2027.That's why I built this self-service tool, no signup, no email, no paywal

Hacker NewsToolAISource
0Sign in to voteCopy link

FL score

72

out of 100

Verdict

VALIDATE

high confidence

Competition

No competitor data yet

Trend

No signal yet

Free tool that helps musicians claim their share of $656M in unclaimed mechanical royalties before the MLC distributes it to major publishers by default in January 2027.

The pain

Musicians and songwriters lose mechanical royalties to the MLC's 'black box' due to registration gaps, metadata issues, or administrative oversights. Without action, $76.61M annually gets redistributed to major publishers via market share rules starting January 2027. Individual creators have no way to know if they're owed money or how to claim it.

The gap

The MLC provides no self-service tool for creators to check unclaimed balances or understand their eligibility. The process requires navigating complex registration requirements, metadata matching, and legal frameworks. Most independent artists don't know this money exists or that they have a deadline.

Build angle

Start with the free lookup tool (already built, no paywall). Validate user demand and pain points. Then layer in a paid service: guided registration assistance, metadata correction, claim filing, and ongoing publishing administration. The creator has existing publishing admin experience and a real business (Doubly) that can monetize downstream. The tool itself is the customer acquisition engine.

Strengths

  • Solves a real, time-bound problem with a hard deadline (January 2027) that creates urgency
  • Massive addressable market: hundreds of thousands of independent musicians globally
  • Clear regulatory tailwind: MMA created the problem and the deadline
  • Creator has domain expertise and existing business infrastructure
  • Free tool removes friction and builds trust before monetization
  • Quantified opportunity: $656M unclaimed, $76.61M annual distribution starting soon
  • Low competition: no existing tools solve this specific problem at scale

Risks

  • Regulatory risk: MLC could change market share rules or extend deadlines, reducing urgency
  • Execution risk: MLC metadata matching is complex; false positives/negatives could damage credibility
  • Monetization risk: creators may resist paying for help claiming their own money; margins depend on volume
  • Market risk: most independent musicians are price-sensitive and may not convert to paid services
  • Dependency risk: entire business depends on MLC data access and cooperation
  • Scaling risk: two-person team at Doubly cannot handle hundreds of thousands of claims manually
  • Churn risk: one-time transaction (claim money once) means customer lifetime value is low unless you build ongoing publishing admin

Questions about this idea?

FlyBot reads the scoring and gives you a second opinion on “Check if any of the $656M in unclaimed royalties at The MLC is yours”.

Open FlyBot