Bramble – Local-first password manager

I'm currently working on Bramble, an open source password manager with P2P cross-device sync. Initially I released the Chrome extension, but recently I also published the Android app and iOS is pending Apple's approval. Besides that, the latest version also includes passkey storage for all platforms!About Bramble:It aims to be as feature-rich as all popular and a replacement for cloud-based providers. I don't think we need to store our data in the cloud and be at the whims of companies raising their prices every year. There's always a breach and then we find out that some fields aren't encrypted, metadata is visible, and so on. I'm frustrated with this and the increasing lack of transparency during these breaches.The P2P sync in Bramble uses a Nostr relay (which can be self-hosted) to keep your devices in sync. The relay just introduces the devices to each other; the data then flows directly over WebRTC, so there's no vault server and no cloud copy of your passwords anywhere. What leaves your device is end-to-end encrypted and your devices authenticate each other directly, so a snooping or MITM relay gets practically nothing.Crypto is all done in Rust so I can control exactly how key material lives and dies in memory (secrets get zeroed out, no GB leaving copies lying around). In Chromium it's a wasm module, on mobile it's native builds bridged over via uniffi.Android app:I'm still deciding whether to publish the app on Play store or simply provide the signed APK which users can sideload. Reason for that is Google's plan to lock down Android and take away ownership from its users. Read more about it here: https://keepandroidopen.com/The app uses no Play APIs whatsoever and runs perfectly on GrapheneOS, where I actually did all my testing.Questions, feedback, feature requests - all welcome!TL;DR: I dislike private-equity and venture funded companies messing with our security, so I created my own Pa

Hacker NewsToolAISource
0Sign in to voteCopy link

FL score

62

out of 100

Verdict

VALIDATE

medium confidence

Competition

No competitor data yet

Trend

No signal yet

Open-source, peer-to-peer password manager that eliminates cloud storage and vendor lock-in by syncing encrypted data directly between user devices.

The pain

Users are trapped in a cycle with cloud password managers: recurring subscription fees, repeated security breaches revealing unencrypted metadata, zero transparency during incidents, and forced dependency on companies that prioritize growth over security. People want control over their credentials but lack a viable alternative that doesn't require technical expertise.

The gap

Existing password managers (1Password, Bitwarden, LastPass) all rely on centralized servers. Self-hosted options exist but require DevOps knowledge. No mainstream solution combines ease-of-use with true local-first architecture and P2P sync across devices without a vault server.

Build angle

The technical foundation is solid, Rust crypto, WebRTC direct sync, Nostr relay architecture, and multi-platform coverage (Chrome, Android, iOS pending). The real work now is converting technical superiority into user adoption. Focus on: (1) making the onboarding frictionless for non-technical users, (2) proving sync reliability across real-world network conditions, (3) building trust through independent security audits, (4) creating a clear monetization path that doesn't contradict the open-source ethos.

Strengths

  • Technical architecture is genuinely differentiated, P2P sync with no vault server is harder to build but eliminates the single point of failure that plagues competitors
  • Open-source foundation creates credibility in security-conscious segments and enables community auditing
  • Multi-platform coverage (Chrome, Android, iOS) matches user expectations for password managers
  • Passkey support positions the product ahead of the curve as the industry shifts away from passwords
  • Founder has deep technical conviction and has already shipped working code across three platforms

Risks

  • User acquisition is extremely difficult in password managers, switching costs are high, trust is low, and most users are already locked into a solution. No clear go-to-market strategy articulated.
  • Monetization is undefined. Open-source + no cloud = no obvious revenue model. Freemium, paid tiers, or donations all conflict with the anti-VC positioning.
  • Sync reliability at scale is unproven. P2P systems are notoriously fragile when devices are offline, networks are poor, or relay infrastructure fails. One bad sync experience loses users permanently.
  • Security audits are expensive and necessary before enterprise or security-conscious users will switch. No mention of audit plans or funding for them.
  • iOS approval is pending, Apple's app review process is unpredictable for privacy-focused tools. Rejection or restrictions could derail the multi-platform strategy.
  • Nostr relay dependency creates a new trust assumption. Even if self-hosted, most users won't run their own relay, so they're trusting a third party (just not the password manager company). This undermines the core value proposition.
  • Distribution through sideloading on Android severely limits addressable market. Most users won't sideload; Play Store rejection means missing 99% of Android users.
  • Competing against well-funded, established players (Bitwarden, 1Password) with massive user bases and brand trust. Differentiation on architecture doesn't matter if users never hear about it.

Questions about this idea?

FlyBot reads the scoring and gives you a second opinion on “Bramble – Local-first password manager”.

Open FlyBot