Fly Labs
Ask FlyBot

Open-source private home security camera system (end-to-end encryption)

Hey everyone,I previously introduced an open source private home security camera in 2024, which uses OpenMLS for end-to-end encryption: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42284412.It was called Privastead then and it's now renamed to Secluso.John Kaczman found my project from here and has been working on it with me over the last year and half. We've made a lot of improvements to the software, which we would like to share with you:- You can now set this up on your Raspberry Pi in less than 5 minutes with no technical expertise using our easy-to-use GUI deploy tool. We've put together a comprehensive build-your-own guide that walks you through the required steps (you can find a link at the top of the repository README).- We use a customized, minimal OS based on the Yocto project for the camera.- Every part of our stack except for the iOS app has reproducible builds. This includes our Android app, camera/server binaries, deploy tool, and the aforementioned OS.- We've re-designed our mobile app, which is now on the iOS App Store and Google Play store.- We now support UnifiedPush for more privacy-preserving push notifications.Looking forward to seeing what you all think!

Hacker NewsToolDevSource
0Sign in to voteCopy link

FL score

62

out of 100

Verdict

VALIDATE

medium confidence

Competition

No competitor data yet

Trend

No signal yet

Open-source home security camera with end-to-end encryption that runs on Raspberry Pi, targeting privacy-conscious users who distrust cloud-based systems.

The pain

Homeowners want security cameras but fear data breaches, government surveillance, or vendor lock-in. Commercial options (Ring, Wyze, Nest) store footage on company servers. Self-hosted alternatives require technical expertise or expensive hardware.

The gap

The market has open-source projects (Frigate, MotionEye) but they lack encryption and polished UX. Commercial systems have UX but sacrifice privacy. Secluso attempts both but hasn't proven it can scale beyond early adopters or generate revenue.

Build angle

Focus on the 5-minute setup and reproducible builds as proof of execution quality. Test willingness-to-pay through: (1) hardware bundles (pre-configured Raspberry Pi kits), (2) optional cloud backup with E2E encryption, (3) professional installation service. Measure retention and feature requests from current users before expanding.

Strengths

  • Technical credibility: reproducible builds, OpenMLS encryption, minimal OS design show serious engineering
  • Low friction entry: 5-minute setup removes biggest barrier to adoption for non-technical users
  • Dual app store presence (iOS + Android) indicates real product-market validation work
  • Open-source model builds trust in privacy-sensitive category and enables community contributions
  • Founder has maintained project for 1.5+ years with co-founder, showing commitment

Risks

  • No clear monetization model stated. Open-source + free software = unsustainable without revenue stream
  • Competing against entrenched players (Ring, Wyze) with massive marketing budgets and existing user bases
  • Hardware costs (Raspberry Pi, cameras, networking) may exceed user willingness-to-pay for DIY segment
  • Privacy-first positioning limits addressable market to ~5-10% of home security buyers
  • Maintenance burden: supporting multiple platforms, OS updates, security patches requires ongoing resources
  • No evidence of user growth metrics, churn rate, or feature adoption data shared publicly

Questions about this idea?

FlyBot reads the scoring and gives you a second opinion on “Open-source private home security camera system (end-to-end encryption)”.

Open FlyBot